Saturday, June 1, 2013

In Praise of Cold


Recently, we had a lot of guests coming to Boston for the wedding of our daughter. Many of them came from the warmer part of the country, like California, and they were quite vociferous in their displeasure of having to spend a few days in New England’s late winter.

This made me think—why is there such a resistance against cold weather?

I not only have no problems with cold, I actually prefer colder climate than hot. Perhaps it has to do with growing up in the extreme heat of an arid part of India. In those days, an air-conditioned room was bliss (we did not have any), and going for vacation in the cold areas, such as a “hill station,” was heaven. Perhaps that experience has shaped me into being who I am.

However, I am convinced that one does not have to be me to enjoy cold weather; I feel that the resistance against it is entirely irrational.

First of all, most of us get exposed to weather only when we step outside. Our homes are comfortably heated or cooled and so are our cars. Many of those who complain about cold hardly step outside these comfortable cocoons, so what difference does it make to them whether they live in cold climate or hot?

Second, when you do step outside, you can always protect yourself against cold by wearing warm cloths. You cannot do that when the outside is very hot. After peeling off that last layer of clothing, you just have to endure heat. So, as it turns out, you are more likely to be cooped up inside if you live in a hot place than in a cold one.

Third, it is more likely that the interior is heated in a cold place than cooled in a warm one. Air-conditioning is expensive and not considered essential. I lived without it when I was growing up in India. Even now I experience hot non-air-conditioned rooms in our own house (we do not have central AC), or when we stay in inexpensive hotels in many parts of the world. So, not only are you miserable walking outside in a hot place but also being inside. The same will not be true if you lived in a cold place.

Fourth, you feel more invigorated and healthy in a cold environment than hot. Being sweaty and perspiring does not lead to having a lot of fun. Lethargy takes over and the level of activity is curtailed.

If, by these arguments, I have convinced you that cold is not all that bad, and even could be good, you may be able to get more out of your life.

For instance, I don’t know how many times I have heard folks telling me that they would not go to Antarctica because they are afraid of being cold.  This irrational fear is keeping them from experiencing one of the most magical places in the world. (By the way, Antarctica in summer is warmer than Boston in winter.)

Also, unless you are living in the extreme north, most places that have cold winter also have distinct spring, summer, and fall. This four-season living provides you with constant change, and most people would agree that change is an important element in being happy. One can get bored if there is no change, no matter how “good” the situation is.

As an illustration, I go for walks on nearby trails in woods and around ponds, camera in my hand. Every time I go, I see something different.  The leaves turn from light green to dark green and then red and orange. Water turns to snow and ice. Birds come and go. The sunlight comes at different angles as the year progresses.

Try to get this variation and freshness in a place where the weather remains the same year around. 

5 comments:

  1. One more discovery that the world is not ruled by rationality, where the heart triumphs over the mind!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Ashok,

    I have lived in NY and Minnesota in between my long stays in California and have experienced both. I definitely dislike extreme heat like the one in So. California the most. While a few years ago I thought that temperature in teh 70s was ideal, since I have moved to San Francisco from South Bay, I now prefer 60s to 70s. So a lot is a matter of getting used to the weather. Having said that, what I really hate about cold climates is not the cold but things like having to wear extra layers, shoveling snow from driveway, scraping ice of the snow, the fear from getting stuck in cold, grey depressing feeling in the winter, inability to ride a bike or play tennis outdoors, etc. So you can have your cold and I am sticking to California!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Tushar: No one can deny the fact that San Francisco has fine weather. Also, it is true that the chores one needs to do in winter can be boring for some people. However, that is the price one has to pay to live in a place with four seasons. Some people like it, some don't. This is my personal preference. Broiling in the 90s weather today, I long for cooler days.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Ashok:

    The reasons for liking or disliking cold may be quite physiologic. For survival, we need the body to operate at a temperature of + or - 98.6 F. The body, generally, finds it easier to disperse heat rather than conserve heat. We lose heat by the dilation of the blood vessels on the skin, thus allowing more blood to flow to the skin surface and disperse the heat through the skin. In the case of cold, the body needs to constrict the blood vessels on the skin to prevent heat loss. Now, there is a limit to constriction, because blood also brings nutrients that will allow the skin to maintain its health. That is why, in extreme cold, the body induces shivering, which is nothing but muscle contraction that burns the glucose in the muscles, and generates more heat. Now shivering is an unpleasant experience - you have no control over your muscles, and you cannot do any normal activity till you get the body to stop the shivering. One can, perhaps, even postulate that "nature" prefers warmth, as all tropical (warm) places have more people surviving than the colder (northern) climes.

    Your other point was about the beauties of winter and the charms of the "change of seasons". I could not agree more with the beauty and charms of the changes produced when seasons change. And you (and me)are in good company with this sentiment. After all Tchaikovsky did write beautiful music in praise of the 4 seasons. As far as I know, he has not done the same with hot weather. The beauty of winter with snow is fantastic for us in the Northeast. But if we take it to the extreme, I am not sure that I could live in a region had winter and snow, year-round.

    So it begs the question:
    Where would you stay if the choices were

    a) say "northern Scandinavia" with 10-11 months of winter, and 1-2 months of warmer weather,
    b) say "Malaysia", with 10-11 months of hot weather and 1-2 months of cooler weather?

    Of course we ignore the "desirability of location" factors, and just focus on climates

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anil, thanks for such a detailed and thoughtful response. IN terms of place to live, my answer would be neither. I refer a place with 4 months of winter or summer, not 10-11 :-)

      Delete