Saturday, August 1, 2015

Of immigrants and race

I finished reading an interesting book by a Nigerian author Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie. Titled “Americanah” it describes in vivid details the life of two fictional characters who grew up in Nigeria but spent time in US, and UK. What make it especially colorful are people and experiences they encounter in their journey.

We who grew up in India, also a developing country like Nigeria, can easily relate to what the author describes in the first part of the book, the life in the “old country.”
 
For example, a rich Nigerian woman tells one of the main characters of the book, Obinze, “You must send your child to the French school. If you want to disadvantage your child by sending to one of these schools with half-baked Nigerian teachers, then you only have yourself to blame.”

That reminded me of a conversation one of my father’s friends had with my parents. “You should send Ashok to this exclusive school (yes, we had one in the town where I grew up) whose headmaster is an Englishman. How can you send him to a Gujarati school, where all the common folks go?”  Thankfully my parents ignored him and I did not turn out to be too bad for the experience, just like Obinze.

The other main character of the book, Ifemelu, leaves Nigeria and arrives in US. She does encounter racism, as can be expected. However, as the story is set in the Northeast (New Jersey, Maryland, Massachusetts), this treatment is not overt. True, she has difficulty in finding a job, due to the covert racism, but at the same time, most of the white folks she encounters are nice to her, almost overcompensating in their attempts not to sound racist or uncaring rich.    

For Kimberly (a white upper-middle class woman), the poor were blameless. Poverty was a gleaming thing; she could not conceive of poor people being vicious or nasty because their poverty had canonized them, and the greatest saints were foreign poor.

In describing another encounter with upper-middle class white Americans; Ifemelu observed that Americans use the word “wonderful” too often. “In Tanzania, we had a wonderful tour guide. We are making donations to a wonderful charity in Malawi, a wonderful orphanage in Botswana, and a wonderful microfinance cooperative in Kenya.”

Just substitute India for all the African countries, and that would be the conversation I have had with so many people in this wonderful country.  I remember an instance when one of my friends, upon looking at picture of one of my aunts said that she looked so pretty. That was not the adjective I had ever heard in connection with that particular aunt. However, my friend was overcompensating and making sure that I would not think she co-relates color of the skin and prettiness.

One of the most interesting parts of the book describes Ifemelu’s interactions with the African Americans. When her Blog about the experience of being black in America is being discussed by a group of African Americans, one rather pompous character says, “You know Ifemelu can write that Blog because she is an African. She is writing from the outside. She does not really feel all the stuff she is writing about. It’s all quaint and curious to her. So she can write it and get all the accolades. If she were African American, she would just be labeled angry and be shunned.”

In my bachelor days, I had a number of friends from Nigeria, Ghana and the Cameroons. One of them had married an African American woman. I had always assumed that there was a common thread between them, both being black and of African heritage. How stupid I was. The marriage did not last long at all. My friend, just could not get along with his strong minded and independent wife, who was all American, and hardly African.

Ifemelu made the same mistake. When she did not participate in a college protest against an injustice suffered by a black security guard, her African American boy friend just could not understand. He accused her not merely about her laziness, her lack of zeal and conviction, but also about her Africanness; she was not sufficiently furious because she was an African, not African American.

I can imagine our children facing a similar (but actually reverse) situation when dealing with people from India, who would assume a certain level of Indianness in them that they do not have. That is a continuing story of the great melting pot that our country is.


This is a very worthwhile book to read on multiple levels. It makes you think more deeply about immigrants and race, and about developing and developed world. It also makes you aware of what it is like being black in this world.

5 comments:

  1. Somehow I feel that overcompensating is fine - its through the goodness of one's heart that one overcompensates (maybe the mind is not 100% but at least the heart is).
    Also, I think it is very, very difficult to truly empathize with African Americans - they are so cutoff from our experiences in America, that we have simply no idea. Just can't get underneath their skin, and upbringing and conditioning. And this is just as true for the whites in America - an impossible task for them. Does even Obama empathize?

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree with you on the first point, but not sure about the second. First it is hard to generalize, second we have been able to empathize with the other groups/races so I am not sure why it could not be African Americans.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Ashok, a couple of reasons why I feel I cannot empathize (I do sympathize immensely) - first, I spent just a few days with Rajiv in Brooklyn a couple of days ago, and felt like a fish out of water. Despite having lived in the US for so long, I felt so "foreign" in Brooklyn's black neighborhoods. Second, again with all the years I spent in the US, I had no clue how rampant was Ferguson, the chokehold on Eric Garner, the “broken tail-light killing in South Carolina, and other such incidents that have surfaced in the last 12 months – how common is this to their life in the United States? Can anyone who does not live through this every day, ever “know” what it is to live as an African American?

    For a long time, I thought these were all random events, an occasional "bad" or fearful cop, or excessive provocation. Now after watching all these cellphone videos, many of these appear to be deliberate acts of violence.
    Vijay

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You are right, it is difficult to put ourselves in their shoes. I wish I had more involvement in that community and perhaps gain better understanding. IN any case, do read the book. I think you will like it.

      Delete