Sunday, July 1, 2012

Tradition and Darwin


The Darwin’s theory of natural selection is amazing. It neatly explains how various species evolved through mutation and subsequent survival of the fittest. Originally developed for explaining how nature operates, the theory has found applicability in explaining all types of things.

If you replace mutation by innovation, new products evolve all the time, albeit at a faster pace than mutations. Of these products, the ones best meet the needs of the customers (‘fittest”) survive. The others die.

Same thing applies in activities we learn and perform. We all need to keep up with the times. If we do not learn how to use the modern communication tools or conveyances, we will be left behind. No one would employ us and socially we will be rejected.

People adapt, businesses evolve and products change---just the way it happens in nature. The old gets replaced by new.

The only place where old remains old is in traditions and rituals. The world changes but the rituals do not.

At a recent wedding, the groom rode a horse and the bride arrived on a palanquin, the way she would have hundreds of years ago. The music was created using conch shells. The priest conducted the ceremony in Sanskrit that no one in the audience understood.

If the Darwin’s theory held true, the groom would have arrived on a Segway (more efficient and consumes no grass), the bride in a golf cart (four wheels instead of four people). The music would have been modern (uses less energy and is more appealing) and the priest would have transferred the wisdom through a power-point presentation--- in English.

But that was not the case---why?

Simply because the attributes such as efficiency and effectiveness of what is being done do not apply to rituals. The groom is in no hurry and the priest is not obliged to explain anything to the audience. Correctly performed ritual is supposed to ward of evil and bring peace and happiness. Why that should be so is not questioned.

Under these circumstances, an old ritual that does not adapt to the modern circumstances does not die. Further, there is no incentive to innovate and so nothing ever changes. Perhaps there is even fear of making a change, lest it would upset some deity.

The Darwin’s theory has finally met its match.